The number of carries is not mentioned enough. If Barkley does it with less attempts then there should be no dispute

Don’t forget Eric Dickerson took the record from OJ Simpson playing in one more game than OJ so it’s not a conversation. In my opinion

No. Xtra game says it all.

All of these records don’t mean anything because we are playing more games now and Dickerson played in an era that the defense was built to stop the run, now defenses are built to stop the pass with lighter faster players giving an advantage to these big powerful RB’s like Barkley and Henry.

Fascinating young man, I hope he gets his 101. If he doesn’t he’ll regret leaving early today.

He's also accomplishing this in a very pass heavy league. There's a reason that modern backs rarely even get close to this achievement. Him and Derrick Henry are outliers in what has become a "big play or bust" NFL.

He had an extra game. Fact

But he didn't get those carries. If he did we wouldn't have this discussion

I know it doesn’t fit your narrative, but Adrian Peterson 2012 season is for superior than saquans. AP had 2097 yards on 348 carries. Saquan 2005 on 345. 92 more yards. That was also with a 💩 QB. They’d put it 8 in the box and you still couldn’t stop. That man

OJ did it in 14. When someone beats that, I’ll be impressed.