2024-09-10 05:54
How come musicians are getting hip to music theory but songwriters aren’t getting hip to grammar?
回覆
轉發

作者

Hexspa
hexspa
粉絲
串文
255+

回覆

轉發

24小時粉絲增長

無資料

互動率

(讚 + 回覆 + 轉發) / 粉絲數
NaN%

回覆 (BETA)

最先回覆的內容
發文後用戶內容
2 小時內
Siobhán Sarelle
siobhansarelle
This is not a thing that is really happening though. It's just some people on some media getting snobby about music. There have always been people who are more snobby about language (because it is about language and people, not music) than others. It's snobbery because it implies that one way is better than another. As with poetry, there are the dry ass 'intellectual' snobs, and there is the 'street'.
10 小時內
Stuart Hoskins
stuarthoskins
Parallel harmony, serialism, music that isnt western art(ragas,maqim) even jazz got away with what were once considered “errors”. Same reason people arent singing like Shakespeare, language changes and popular art follows the rules of the target audience.
13 小時內
Jeff Levesque
jeffus_levesqueus
Which songwriters?
14 小時內
Jonathon Piccolo
thebassjon
Songwriters don't write in perfect grammar for the same reason most people don't speak in perfect grammar. Dialects are a reflection of different societal "clans", so to speak. We speak in different ways that appeal to others in our own clan. Lyrics written in academically perfect English would appeal to the highbrow academic clan but alienate everyone else. That's not exactly how you top the charts.
17 小時內
Mark Westin
penguinlust
don’t get me weong, i’m a word guy all the way and i love a well turned phrase. but songwriting is also about visceral and emotional impact, and sometimes just sonic impact- the sound of the lyrics can be as important as the words themselves. in those cases, good grammar is less important to me than putting across whatever larger point i’m trying to make with the song.
17 小時內
Andy Allwood | Soulful House DJ/ Producer
andyallwood
I blame that early 2000s track The Way I Are 🤣

© 2025 Threadser.net. 版權所有。

Threadser.net 與 Meta Platforms, Inc. 無關,未經其認可、贊助或特別批准。

Threadser.net 也不與 Meta 的"Threads" 產品存在任何關聯。